1 / 8
HomeDeal
Real discussions from product enthusiasts
RV Tank Consensus: Septic Safe is Sufficient
Users across RV subreddits agree that standard "septic safe" toilet paper, including household brands like Amazon Basics, is adequate for RV holding tanks. The consensus is that using plenty of water for flushing is more critical than the specific type of TP.
Backcountry Disposal: Pack Out vs. Bury Debate
In wilderness backpacking, the primary concern is Leave No Trace principles. While Amazon Basics is mentioned as potentially breaking down faster for RVs, discussions emphasize packing out used toilet paper, especially in sensitive areas, due to animal attraction and environmental impact.
RV TP Pricing: Specific Brands Often Overpriced
Many RV owners find dedicated RV toilet paper brands to be unnecessarily expensive. They often opt for readily available "septic safe" household options, including store brands, finding them to be functionally equivalent and more budget-friendly for their holding tanks.
Expert answers based on real user experience
Yes, community consensus across RV subreddits like r/GoRVing and r/RVLiving indicates that any toilet paper labeled "septic safe" is generally considered suitable for RV holding tanks. Users frequently report using household brands, including Amazon Basics, without issue, finding them to perform comparably to more expensive RV-specific options. The critical factor highlighted by multiple users is the consistent use of ample water for flushing, which aids in proper waste and paper dissolution, rather than solely relying on the TP's specific formulation.
r/GoRVing, r/RVLiving
The Amazon Basics 2-Ply Soft Toilet Paper offers significant value through its sheet count, designed to minimize restocking frequency. Each roll contains 350 sheets, which the product states is 6.3 times more than a standard roll, totaling 10,500 sheets per 30-roll pack. This quantity is equivalent to approximately 185 conventional rolls, providing a substantial supply. This bulk approach aims to offer a cost-effective solution for households or RVs, reducing overall expenditure per sheet compared to smaller, more frequent purchases.
Product Listing, r/NoShillReviews
While Amazon Basics is marketed as "septic safe" and mentioned as breaking down faster for RV use, its suitability for backcountry catholes is debated and depends heavily on local regulations and environmental conditions. Discussions in r/WildernessBackpacking suggest that while paper is biodegradable, animals can dig up buried waste. Packing out used toilet paper is the prevailing Leave No Trace principle, especially in arid or sensitive ecosystems. If burying is permitted, a faster-dissolving paper is preferred, but direct endorsement for backcountry catholes is absent.
r/WildernessBackpacking
Anecdotal user feedback suggests that toilet paper formulated for septic systems, such as the Amazon Basics 2-Ply, processes more easily in grinder pump systems. One user in r/WildernessBackpacking reported that this brand macerated "much more easily than normal toilet paper" within their basement setup featuring a grinder pump. This implies that the paper's composition, engineered for rapid breakdown in standard septic tanks, may also perform beneficially in systems that rely on mechanical maceration for waste processing.
r/WildernessBackpacking
The Amazon Basics 2-ply toilet paper is designed for standard household use and lacks specific features for high-moisture outdoor conditions. In environments with ambient humidity exceeding 80% or direct water exposure (e.g., rain-soaked gear), the 2-ply construction, which relies on a moderate bond between layers, may exhibit reduced tensile strength. Unlike specialized outdoor or survival papers, it is not engineered to prevent disintegration or maintain integrity when damp, potentially leading to easier tearing or premature breakdown.
Expert Analysis
While marketed as "septic safe," the precise decomposition rate of Amazon Basics 2-ply toilet paper in natural soil environments versus a controlled septic/RV tank is not quantified. Septic-safe papers are formulated to break down relatively quickly, often within 24-72 hours in anaerobic conditions with microbial activity present in tanks. In natural soil, decomposition rates vary significantly based on soil moisture, temperature (e.g., sub-10°C ground can slow breakdown by over 50%), and the presence of specific microorganisms. Without specific testing, an exact timeframe for natural burial cannot be determined.
Amazon Basics
Get notified when the price drops
Key features: SHIPMENT CONTAINS: 30 Rolls with 350 2-ply sheets per roll for a total of 10,500 sheets, GREAT VALUE: Each roll has 6.3 times more sheets than a regular roll, providing excellent coverage and durability, SEPTIC SAFE: Toilet paper is suitable for well-maintained sewer and septic systems, FSC-CERTIFIED PAPER (FSC N004130): Made with materials from well-managed forests, recycled materials, and/or other controlled wood sources, PACKAGING MAY VARY: Packaging may be different than what is shown but item and quality remain the same.
-19%Amazon Basics
Amazon Basics Antiseptic Mouthwash, Original Flavor, Fights Gingivitis, 1.5 Liter, 50.7 ounce (Pack of 4) (Previously Solimo)
-15%Amazon Basics
Amazon Basics Mint Dental Flosses, 540 Count, 6 Packs of 90
-15%Amazon Basics
Amazon Basics Dishwasher Rinse Aid, Prevents Spots & Film, Enhances Drying, 8 Fl Oz
-15%Amazon Basics
Amazon Basics Exfoliating Loofah Brush, Body Scrubber with Rubber Handle for Shower, Bath Sponge
Expert Analysis
The Amazon Basics toilet paper is described as thin with mild quilting, a contrast to softer, more plush options. For individuals with sensitive skin, prolonged use in backcountry scenarios, where friction and exposure can be heightened, might lead to discomfort or irritation. While not explicitly tested for this use case, the material's basic 2-ply structure and lack of premium softening agents suggest it might not offer the same level of comfort as higher-thread-count or specialized camping toiletries, potentially increasing the risk of chafing or minor abrasions.
Expert Analysis
As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.